Direct Loan Comparison Chart

Category
FFELP
(i.e., Stafford Loan, Parent PLUS Loan, and Grad PLUS Loan)
Direct Lending
(i.e., Direct Loan, Parent PLUS Direct Loan, and Grad PLUS Direct Loan)
Annual and Aggregate Loan Limits
The same annual and aggregate loan limits that apply to the Stafford Loan Program also apply to the Direct Loan Program
Borrower Benefits
Legislation passed by Congress prior to the current economic issues led to the elimination of borrower benefits. It costs more for lenders to make Stafford loans now.   A strengthened economy will not bring back these benefits.  Benefits are practically non-existent on new loans.  Benefits on older loans may be lost when the loan is sold.
The legislative changes that led to reduced benefits in FFELP did not reduce Direct Loan benefits. In some cases, it actually strengthened them (e.g., Public Loan Forgiveness, etc.).  Additionally, benefits remain with the loan through the duration of repayment.
Eligibility Criteria
The criteria used to determine who is eligible for Stafford Loan and Direct Loan is identical.
Fees (interest Rate) for Subsidized and Unsubsidized Loans
The maximum interest rate a lender can charge is set by Congress, and is the same rate for FFELP and Direct Loans.
Fees (Up Front)
Students with FFELP Stafford Loans are generally charged a 1% Default Fee on the loan before disbursement.  In some cases, the fee may be higher.
Direct Loan borrowers are charged a net .5% (half of a percent) fee on the loan before disbursement.  This means the student receives more money from each loan disbursement.
Income Contingent Repayment (ICR)
FFELP does not have this program. It offers the Income Sensitive Repayment plan, which is not as flexible as ICR.
Having Direct Loans meets one of the criteria for this program.  ICR can make loans less expensive for qualifying borrowers who are struggling with repayment.
Interest Capitalization
Interest may be capitalized at a higher rate than with Direct Loans.
Interest capitalized at less than statutory maximum.
Loan Consolidation
Due to the legislation changes and economic issues, the majority of lenders are not offering loan consolidation any longer. Many companies specializing in loan consolidation have gone out of business.
Consolidation remains a viable option.  Students can consolidate their FFELP Loans with the Direct Loans when they enter repayment if they so choose.
Loan Process
The FFELP process often leads to confusion due to the complexities associated in working with multiple lenders, servicers, and guaranty agencies.
Direct Lending provides a much more streamlined flow for loans, which makes navigating the process much simpler for borrowers.
Loan Repayment
Borrowers repay private lenders
Borrowers repay the federal government
Loan Sale
Many lenders are selling their loans to the government via the "PUT" Program to help with their liquidity issues.
Loans are with the federal government and never sold to other lenders, so this provides single servicing for the life of the loan.
Parent PLUS Loan Interest Rate
Parent PLUS Interest Rate is 8.5%
Parent PLUS interest Rate is 7.9%
PLUS Loan Auction
Beginning in 2009-10 a PLUS auction is slated to take place as a result of legislation passed by Congress.  This will limit the lenders available to provide PLUS Loans in each state, and these lenders are subject to change every two years when a new auction takes place.
The PLUS Loan Auction does not apply to Direct Loans as the lender is the federal government.
Public Service Loan Forgiveness
This is not an option under FFELP, as you can only qualify for this with Direct Loans.
Having Direct Loans meets one of the criteria for this program.
Stability
Many lenders have left the FFELP due to issues with liquidity, forcing borrowers to find new lenders.  This trend is likely to continue in the future.
The liquidity issues that are impacting FFELP lenders are not affecting Direct Loans.  The funding source for Direct Loans is more stable.
For answers to the most commonly asked questions concerning Direct Loans, including the steps each borrower needs to take in order to apply for a Direct Loan, please go to http://www.jmu.edu/finaid/directloanfaq.shtml.